One question I get asked regularly by local companies: Should I hire a Generative Engine Optimization agency near me? Or does it not matter because everything is digital now?
The honest answer is: it matters less than it used to, but it might still matter for your situation. Let me walk through when location is important and when it’s not.
The Case For Remote Agencies
The internet has fundamentally changed agency relationships. You can work with an agency in a different city, state, or even country, and it works just fine.
Advantages of remote/non-local agencies:
-
Bigger talent pool to choose from
-
Agencies don’t have to pay local rent, so they’re often cheaper
-
You’re not locked into local expertise (which might not exist for GEO yet)
-
Time zones can actually work in your favor (work gets done while you sleep)
-
Remote work often means better communication systems and discipline
For GEO specifically, location is almost irrelevant. They’re not coming to your office. They’re analyzing your content, your competitors, and your position in AI systems—all of which are digital.
The Case For Local Agencies
That said, there are some situations where local agencies matter:
In-person collaboration: If you want agency people in your office regularly, that works better with local agencies.
Client entertainment/relationship building: Some traditional agencies build relationships through in-person meetings, dinners, events. If that matters to you, local might matter.
Local market expertise: If you’re optimizing for local search or your market is highly geographically specific, local agencies might have relevant context.
Timezone alignment: If you need same-day turnaround and real-time collaboration, being in the same timezone helps.
Personal relationships: If you value meeting your team in person, local matters.
The GEO-Specific Reality
For GEO specifically, I’d argue location matters even less:
GEO isn’t geographically dependent. An AI system doesn’t care where the agency is that optimized your content.
The expertise needed for GEO is specialized enough that it might not exist locally. Depending on your location, the best GEO agencies might not be near you.
GEO work is highly digital and doesn’t require in-person collaboration.
The best agencies in your space might be across the country or internationally.
How to Find Non-Local Agencies
If you’re open to remote agencies, here’s how to find good ones:
Search online: Google “GEO service” or “Generative Engine Optimization services.” See who shows up. Often the best agencies are the ones visible in search because they’re practicing what they preach.
Ask your network: Who are other marketers using? What agencies have they heard about?
Check LinkedIn: Look for agencies or consultants with GEO expertise. See where they’re based.
Research communities: There are Slack groups, Reddit communities, and forums where marketers discuss agency recommendations.
Check industry publications: If your industry has publications or analyst firms, they often review agency providers.
The geographic origin of the agency is less important than whether they can demonstrate expertise.
The Virtual Collaboration Tools Reality
By now, remote collaboration tools are good enough that location doesn’t matter much:
You can do video calls with people worldwide. You can collaborate on documents in real-time. You can manage projects across time zones. You can screen share and work together synchronously or asynchronously.
The agencies that are good at remote work are actually often better at communication and documentation than traditional local agencies (because they have to be).
What Actually Matters More Than Location
If you’re trying to decide between agencies, focus on these factors rather than location:
Expertise: Do they understand GEO? Can they articulate a clear methodology?
Track record: Have they done this successfully before?
Communication style: Do you like how they communicate? Are they responsive?
Cultural fit: Does the team feel like people you’d want to work with?
Price: Does the pricing make sense for the value they’re providing?
Availability: Can they take on your project and give you adequate resources?
References: Can they provide references from similar companies?
These factors matter infinitely more than whether they’re in your city.
When Location Actually Matters
To be fair, there are some situations where Generative Engine Optimization agency near me is genuinely important:
Complex in-person needs: If you need agency people regularly on-site collaborating with your team, local helps.
Large, traditional companies: Some enterprise companies still prefer to work with local vendors they can meet with regularly.
Local service businesses: If you’re optimizing for local search (restaurants, plumbers, doctors), you might want an agency that understands your local market.
Time zone critical: If you need same-day response and real-time collaboration, time zone matching helps.
Relationship-dependent work: If the work is relationship-dependent and you want in-person trust-building, local is better.
But for most GEO work? Location doesn’t matter much.
The Cost Benefit Analysis
Local agencies often charge more because they have physical office overhead. Remote agencies often have lower overhead and can charge less.
For the same level of expertise, you might pay 20-30% more for a local agency just because of their location.
Unless location is providing real value to you, is it worth the premium?
The Practical Recommendation
Here’s my advice:
Default to remote: Start by looking at agencies without geographic constraints. Find the best fit based on expertise, experience, and communication.
Consider local only if: You have specific needs that require in-person collaboration or local market expertise.
Interview across geographies: Talk to agencies in different locations. Compare quality, price, and fit.
Make the decision on merit: Pick the best agency, not the closest one.
The Transition to Remote Work
If you’re used to traditional local agency relationships, remote can feel awkward at first. But it gets easier when:
-
You establish clear communication rhythms (weekly calls, monthly reviews)
-
You use good collaboration tools (Slack, Asana, Google Docs, etc.)
-
You set clear expectations about response times
-
You document decisions and reasoning
-
You have regular check-ins
Remote agencies that are good at what they do often have these systems dialed in already.
The Future of Agency Selection
I think the industry is trending toward remote/distributed teams. The best talent isn’t always in your city. The best agencies for specialized services like GEO might not exist locally.
Companies that are flexible about geography have access to better talent and expertise than companies tied to local options.
The Bottom Line
For GEO services, location matters way less than expertise, communication, cultural fit, and track record.
Don’t limit yourself to local agencies unless you have a specific reason. The best GEO partner for your business might be in a different time zone, and that’s completely fine.
Find the best agency, negotiate good terms, set up good communication systems, and let the quality of their work be what matters.
Looking for the best GEO partner regardless of location? Explore ThatWare’s remote-first approach to GEO services that delivers expertise without geographic constraints.
